In 1887, for $2300, the group purchased the land and building that they had been leasing and incorporated themselves as St. Luke’s Episcopal Church. The first vestry members were Theron Pritchard, John Robinson, C.L. Dunbar, B.L. Thompson, R.M. Swift, and A.G. Odell. The church was furnished with an altar and lectern built by Henry Suter and given by Mrs. Swift’s Sunday school class and the Sunday school of Christ Church, Pittsford, respectively; otherwise the interior furnishings were sparse, lacking carpets or any means of heating. Although congregations numbered more than 100 in the early days, by 1897 records show only twenty communicants.
In 1907, Bishop Walker described the Fairport church as “moribund”; however, since the Fairport community was growing rapidly, the pastor at the time, Archdeacon William Davis, was not willing to give up.
He is quoted in a history of the diocese as saying: “Last fall I decided that the best thing to do was to take down the old building and from the debris erect, as far as possible, a new one on more churchly lines. When I announced my purpose to the people, it was received with incredulous looks. They had been dead so long and were so happy in their grave clothes, that they resented even the thought of a resurrection . . . When I started out with a subscription paper, one man offered me fifty cents. In two days, I had a little over one hundred dollars subscribed and one dollar paid in. With this small financial backing, I sent for two carpenters who had worked for me before, and much to the consternation of the people, we began the work of tearing down. Each week I collected the money to pay the men, and by the last of the month, we had, from the old materials, reconstructed and enclosed what promises to be a neat Gothic building, at an expenditure of a little over $400. We need about $400 more to complete the structure . . . I am my own architect, and, as occasion may require, my own builder . . . The people of the town have already had a vision of a man in clerical garb upon the roof of the church laying shingles.”
Apparently, Fr. Davis inspired the small congregation, because by 1924 the mortgage was paid off, and the church had received a number of memorial gifts, including a baptismal font, given in 1907, which is still in use. In 1927, under the leadership of the Rev. Ridgley Lytle, a parish house addition was built which contained a kitchen, an assembly hall, and a heating plant for both the parish hall and the church.
The Depression Years
The parish declined during the years of the Depression. In 1936, for example, there were only 25 pledges. The congregation held services in the parish hall because they lacked money to repair the furnace that heated the church itself, and there was a stove in the parish hall. The church, however, managed to survive. Women were given voting rights in parish elections, and as a result of post World War II growth, a house on West Church Street was purchased for the rectory and, in 1952, St. Luke’s became a self-sustaining parish under the leadership of the Rev. Elwyn Brown.
THE HOPEFUL 50'S
By 1955, there were over 200 households in the parish and there was talk of building a new and larger church. One plan proposed to build a central church for the communities of Perinton, Penfield, and East Rochester; however, a survey indicated that the majority of church members were opposed. Subsequently, the Church of the Incarnation was established in Penfield and St. Luke’s plans for expansion were tabled.
The Tumultuous 60's and 70's
The decade of the 1960's was a tumultuous one for St. Luke’s Church. In 1962, the church and its rector, Dustin Ordway, sold the village property to the Fairport Public Library (who subsequently sold it to the village as the site for the fire hall), and purchased sixteen acres of land on a hill off Ayrault Road is what is now the Brambleridge East subdivision. With the growth in Perinton, the church would now have a more central location in the town. As a result of several bequests, St. Luke’s already had about $91,000 in a capital fund. The proposed new church, designed by noted architect Marcel Breuer, was to be a large, modern, concrete structure. Mr. Breuer declined to work within a budget, and the proposed cost of his plan came to well over $400,000. Issues surrounding the building plans caused significant dissention within the congregation, and eventually the plan was discarded primarily due to lack of sufficient funding. A smaller, prefabricated structure was constructed and opened in 1968 with the hope that it would eventually become a parish hall when and if the Breuer design was ever built. Despite the fact that the town population was growing in the late 60's and early 70's, St. Luke’s did not see significant expansion, perhaps due to the social stresses of that period, changes in the prayer book, issues like the ordination of women, and disagreements over the role the church should play in commenting on social, political, or national issues.
THE GROWING 80'S AND 90'S
During the 1980's, however, the parish enjoyed significant growth which led to a space crunch in the small church building, and some minor remodeling was done to expand both worship and Sunday school space. At the same time, several generous gifts made it possible to purchase a pipe organ to enhance St. Luke’s tradition of excellent music. The congregation has been fortunate in its music directors, which have included two American Guild of Organists national competition winners.
A space problem both for worship and for Sunday school continued to plague St. Luke’s throughout the 1980's, and in 1988 a “Second Century Fund” was established to raise money for a new church building. This time the building project was successful and a more traditional stone building was erected and dedicated in 1990. In addition to a larger worship space, the building includes meeting rooms and Sunday school rooms as well as a columbarium, a room that houses niches for ashes.
The Early 2000's
St. Luke’s undertook a major renovation project in 2004-2007. The original building on our site now has a new roof, new siding, and new windows. Fresh paint and flooring, a more energy efficient and environmentally friendly furnace, and additional fire safety features also enhance the building.
In 2007, a $30,000 grant was received to expand and purchase new equipment for the playground that St. Luke's Church children and our neighborhood share. The playground is one of the ways that we say "welcome" to the people when they come to St. Luke's.
In addition to traditional and creative worship, church school, adult education, youth programs and fellowship events the parish has an active outreach program. A quilting group meets four times a year to create quilts for children in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit at Golisano Children’s Hospital at Strong Hospital. Members of St. Luke’s volunteer as tutors of kindergarteners at School No. 9 in Rochester. St. Luke’s provides volunteers, gifts in kind, and/or financial support for Safe Journey, Advent House, a Meal and More, the Perinton Food Shelf, Fairport Vacation Bible School, Perinton Lay Clergy Council, the Good Neighbor Fund, and Episcopal Senior Life Communities. A Daisy Girl Scout troop also meets at St. Luke’s.
On a national and international level, St. Luke’s supports the United Thank Offering, Episcopal Relief and Development, and Church World Service. Profits from sales of Equal Exchange Coffee provide loans for individuals to begin businesses in third world countries.
As St. Luke’s begins the 21st century, it is committed to fulfilling its goal of “doing God’s work in the world.”